A surcharge adds a fee when a customer pays by credit card; a cash discount shows the card price as the regular price and takes money off for cash or check. Federal law stops the card networks from banning a cash discount, and no state we checked bans one. A surcharge is capped at 3% by Visa, can never be added to a debit card, and is banned outright in Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine and Puerto Rico. Below: the difference, the card rules, a state-by-state table as of November 2026, and how to pick.
This is general information, not legal advice. State laws change; check yours before you start.
What’s the difference between a cash discount and a surcharge?
| Surcharge | Cash discount | |
|---|---|---|
| The price you show | The cash price, plus a card fee at checkout | The card price, with a lower price for cash or check |
| Who pays more | Credit card customers | Card payers pay the listed price; cash payers pay less |
| Debit cards | Can’t be surcharged | Pay the regular (card) price |
| Federal law | Allowed, within card-network rules and state law | Card networks can’t forbid it |
| States that ban it | Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine, Puerto Rico | None found (Puerto Rico may restrict them; check) |
The key is what the price is before anyone pays. With a cash discount, the higher price is the normal price. Federal law says a card network can’t stop a business from offering “a discount or in-kind incentive for payment by the use of cash, checks, debit cards, or credit cards” (15 USC 1693o-2(b)(2)(A)), and where federal or state law requires it, the discount must be offered to everyone and “disclosed clearly and conspicuously.” That limits the card networks; it doesn’t override state law.
A “cash discount” that is really a fee added at checkout gets treated as a surcharge. Visa’s guidance says a genuine discount shows either the card price alone or “both the card and the cash price listed side-by-side,” and that the card price should not be “achieved by applying an additional fee for a card payment” (Visa merchant surcharging Q&A, version dated February 2024).
What are Visa’s surcharge rules?
From the same Visa document:
- Notify your processor first: “at least 30 days prior to commencing surcharging.”
- Credit cards only: “debit cards and prepaid cards cannot be surcharged,” even when a debit card is run as credit.
- Cap: your merchant discount rate (what the card actually costs you) or 3%, “whichever is lowest.”
- Disclose it at the point of entry, at the point of sale, and on every receipt.
Mastercard allows a higher cap, but you can’t know which network a customer will use before they pay, so in practice 3% is the ceiling. A pending Visa and Mastercard settlement could change the surcharge rules; as of November 16, 2026, the court had not ruled on it (Payments Dive).
Hear the receptionist take a real call — it rings your phone in about a minute.
Which states ban or cap credit card surcharges?
Checked November 19, 2026, against the linked statutes or official guidance (rows without a link are from legal summaries; confirm them):
| State | Rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Connecticut | Banned: no fee for the method of payment | CT Dept. of Consumer Protection |
| Massachusetts | Banned on credit cards; cash discounts allowed if offered to all and disclosed | MGL c.140D §28A |
| Maine | Banned on credit and debit cards; a discount is not a surcharge | 9-A MRSA §8-509 |
| Puerto Rico | Banned | Law 150-2008 |
| Oklahoma | Allowed since November 1, 2025, capped at 2% or the actual cost, whichever is less | SB 677 |
| Colorado | Capped at 2% or the merchant discount fee; not on cash, check, debit or gift cards | C.R.S. 5-2-212 |
| New York | No more than the card company charges; the total card price must be posted | GBL §518 |
| New Jersey | No more than your actual cost; disclose before the charge | P.L.2023, c.146 |
| Minnesota | Capped at 5%, with disclosure | Minn. Stat. §325G.051 |
| Louisiana | Debit surcharges banned from August 1, 2026 | Act 751 (SB 254) |
| California | A card fee a customer can avoid by paying another way generally needn’t be in the advertised price, unless you only accept cards (then it must be) | CA Attorney General on SB 478 |
Oklahoma banned surcharges until the 2025 law, and Visa’s own February 2024 list still shows it as banned.
Should a service business choose a cash discount or a surcharge?
A cash discount if you work in a state that bans surcharges, many customers pay by debit (a surcharge can’t touch them, but a cash discount still prices them at the card price), or you’d rather customers feel they’re getting a deal.
A surcharge if most customers pay by credit card, you want your advertised prices to be the cash price, and your state allows it. Expect some customers to dislike seeing a fee line.
Neither if your margins already absorb processing; a 3% fee on a $400 repair is $12, and some owners decide it isn’t worth the conversation.
Either way: put it in writing on your estimate, so the customer agrees to the price before the work starts.
How does Stack Space handle card fees and cash discounts?
Stack Space has both, and you pick one; they can’t be on together.
Cash discount. The prices you type are your cash prices. Customers see the regular (card) price on estimates, invoices and the pay page, with a line like “Pay by cash or check: $X — you save $Y,” and both totals sit above the signature when they approve an estimate. If they pay by card, the card price is what’s charged and recorded.
Card fee (surcharge). Up to 3%, and never more than the card actually costs you: Stripe’s standard price is 2.9% + 30¢, so on larger payments the fee drops to that cost. Debit and prepaid cards can’t be surcharged, and Stripe’s checkout can’t tell them apart before the customer pays, so if a customer pays with one the fee is refunded to their card automatically. The fee is blocked if your service area names Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine or Puerto Rico, and capped at 2% for Colorado or Oklahoma (spell the state out, or write it like “Bangor, ME”). That check reads the service area you entered.
Payments go to your own Stripe account, and invoices go out by email and text with the pay link (more in how to send an invoice by text). When someone pays cash, send a receipt rather than another bill. Charging for the first visit? See service call fees. Plans are $125 a month (Starter) or $355 (Professional), with no free trial.
FAQ
Is a cash discount legal? Generally, yes. Federal law stops the card networks from forbidding a discount for cash or check, Massachusetts and Maine law say a discount is not a surcharge, and we found no state that bans one (Puerto Rico may restrict it). Offer it to everyone and disclose it clearly.
Is credit card surcharging legal in my state? In most states, within Visa’s rules (3% maximum, credit cards only, 30 days’ notice to your processor, disclosed at entry, at checkout and on the receipt), with extra rules in New York, New Jersey, Minnesota and California. It’s banned in Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine and Puerto Rico, and capped lower in Colorado and Oklahoma (2%), as of November 2026.
Can I charge a fee for debit card payments? No. Visa’s rules don’t allow surcharges on debit or prepaid cards, even when run as credit, and Louisiana’s Act 751 bans debit surcharges from August 1, 2026 (per the enrolled bill; confirm with your state).
What’s the maximum credit card surcharge? 3% under Visa’s rules, or your actual processing cost if that’s lower. Some states set lower caps.
What is dual pricing? Showing a card price and a cash price side by side. Done that way, it’s a form of cash discount under Visa’s guidance.
Run your whole business on one platform.
Full CRM + AI included from $125/mo · no contracts · cancel in two clicks
Start today